The Gunfighter Musical cast includes Abby Payne, Jeff Davis, Emily Vetsch, Chelsea Retzloff, Natalie King, Alice Pucheu, Kristen DiMercurio, Michael Hunsaker, Craig Winberry, Amanda Higgins, Ryan Lanning, Joelle Lurie, Marc Andrew Nuñez, Shara Radin, Desire Barns, Randy Burd, Constance Nicolas Vellozzi, Brandon Jones, Christina Watanabe, Jenna Hanlon, Kurt Bradley, Allie Del Principe.